Dr. Peter A. Facione
How often would you say you change your mind about something? Probably not very often – and that’s normal! Human instinct is to make up your mind and stick to your guns. The survival of our species actually depends on this sort of decisiveness. When presented with a situation in which our fight or flight instinct is activated, if we flounder, we die – or at the very least may get injured.
When we naturally bolster a choice we have made, and diminish the value of other options, we are engaging in what is called dominance structuring. Dominance structuring is an important natural decision-making process that can be either rational or irrational. Never-the-less, it is a natural part of our natural way of thinking. For example, a rational use of dominance structuring is when an organization sets goals and objectives and then carries those out through careful leadership and strong staff using measurable performance indicators and objective metrics.
Our natural tendency toward dominance structuring occurs when a decision is made pre-maturely. Often clear evidence will later show that the decision should be reversed, but we avoid facing that reality and lock-in to the decision that is most likely hurting us or our team.
It is difficult to change our own minds, let alone convince someone else that what they decided was not the best. But that is why understanding dominance structing is vital. We can protect ourselves and our businesses from locking in on a decision that should otherwise be thrown out.
Whether we’re talking about a team or an individual, there are four specific steps to decision-making: Evidence shows that we:
(1) Pre-edit
(2) Identify one promising option
(3) Test that option against others
(4) Structure our thinking so that the option we choose comes to dominate the other options
In pre-editing, we defined the problem and identified some possible options using our priorities and preferences to guide us. This is a perfectly reasonable thing to do, especially when we have a moment or two to think things through. Everything should flow nicely from this starting point, that is, if we have correctly understood “the problem” and if we did not forget any critical factors that would otherwise alter our priorities.
The idealized decision-making process we all learned about in school ends here. In the real world we do not impartially and objectively evaluate all our options, listing in our minds (or on paper) all their pros and cons. That just does not happen.
Looking at actual human decision-making, what researchers learned is that we begin going through the options until we find one that looks promising. If one of the options really hits one or two of our “must-have” priorities, we tend to elevate that option in our own minds. We have not decided yet. But we have found the option that we now regard as most promising.
From there we compare all other options to that one. We ask if each of the other options is better than the option we have begun to regard as the most promising option. It takes a lot to be better than that one, and almost always the other options do not measure up. But, if one does obviously surpass the initially most promising option, and if we are being rational, we will elevate that obviously better option into the first position.
If we were to stop here, things might still be reasonable enough. However, the fourth step in our decision-making process is deciding that the option we chose is superior and harden ourselves to any other option or evidence we may have been mistaken. We diminish the value of the other options with criticisms that show why each is lacking. Pushed to an extreme, we may even say something like, “There really wasn’t any other choice.” Or “Why are we wasting our time on these other possibilities when we already know what our only real choice here is?”
Often this process of dominance structing works out well. Our teams and leaders will have assessed a situation effectively and have determined the positive solution from the options presented.
However, sometimes decisions are made prematurely. Perhaps the other options were not given a fair-minded evaluation, or perhaps the quest for other options was simply terminated when the initial most promising option arose. That latter error is a central element in many detective novels. A prime suspect is identified fairly early in the story, and the search for other possible suspects ends. What usually follows in detective fiction is an effort to prove that the prime suspect is guilty. The detective locks in prematurely on that one suspect as the guilty party, only to discover later in the story that the real perpetrator is still out there somewhere.
When the evidence shows that the detective should re-evaluate, it is often difficult for the detective to acknowledge that reality. The same is true in real life. When the evidence comes forward that shows a decision should be re-evaluated it is hard for any of us to make change. How many times have we all watched as the new evidence was casually dismissed or fell upon deaf ears.
In part two of this blog, we will discuss ways for leaders, teachers, parents, and teams to prevent locking in on a decision too early and explore logical dominance structuring to protect our communities and organizations. Part two will be posted on our blog page soon.
Have you enjoyed the content of this post? Subscribe to our email list for updates and get notifications of new content.